Friday, 12 April 2013

Open Letter and Rebuttal to Mr Andre

In the December 2012 edition of Counter Punch, a political newsletter of USA, an article on the apathy of India written by Mr Andre Vltchek was published. Read it here..

This is an open letter and rebuttal to Mr Andre, seeking his lopsided ideological views..

-->

Dear Mr Andre,

One is really sorry to hear and sympathizes with the narration of your horrible times in India. We are sure that the actual agony and pain must have been much more than what you could pen down. In fact, we were surprised that you forgot to mention that you didn't find toilet papers in your hotel room and that Indians prefer to use the appendages at the end of the human arm to clean there manure. Well, nothing much can be done about it, as it is an inheritance. Please don't think that we want to justify our sanitary habits or want to contest your acrimonious and arrogant style of writing sarcasms, which seems to be your only style of writing (a quick search on the internet makes it obvious). In India we are very open to accepting such unidirectional self opinioned comments from people born with a silver spoon. Frankly, as one can see, you don't understand the meaning of a developing nation and associated aspects. 

India, as you have correctly pointed, hypocritically safeguards the country. The contrast of the inconveniences at the airports, metros and hotels viz-a-viz the reactions during riots, slums and elections have been drawn with an excellent articulation. But there is some things which you conveniently chose to forget - the omnipresent threat of an eccentrica and unstable neighbor. We are sure, you won’t understand it much because your shallow research of facts, negativity, distress of being checked frequently and not being allowed to film VVIP locations, which restricted your logical thinking.

After reading your article one gets a sense that you have spend a lot of time in India and other countries also, for which you must have definitely checked-in a numerous times at US airports (where you live). Here are some horror stories which, probably you did not notice or were too busy in your cocooned thoughts.

Embarrassing measures of U.S. airport security check..Read here..   And this.. 
A Mother’s nightmare at US airport….Read here..


We are sure; no one would have done this to you at the wooden box, which you mentioned, because we have our own balls to protect ourselves.

 
-->
Picking selective, advantageous and targeted excerpts from research papers do not justify the arguments of custodial deaths or Kashmir. We don’t think you have been to Kashmir, otherwise you would have mentioned that in your article to display the gallant. In fact, instead of investigating some hard facts of terrorism and the prosperity that Kashmir is making today, you were busy malingering the horrible state of Human Rights violations. One has only heard the abhorrent stories of pissing on prisoners by US soldiers and the numerous muslims, pushtoons and turbaned Indians who disappeared from New York after 9/11. But you see Mr Andre, we didn’t go on with publishing biased, ignorant, disillusioned and cynical point of views.

As Indians, we believe to be pro-active rather than reactive, which in most cases people are. We are sorry that you had to fill a form, surrender a repugnant photograph of yours and may be wait for few hours before making a call. Such measures have been adopted after analyzing the fact that most of the Improvised Explosive Devices are triggered using a mobile phones. Logical reasoning and preventive measures seems to be missing in your biggety dictionary. Condoms must be also not making any sense to you, or do they? Old proverb, just as a tip – “Prevention is better than cure”.

Ahhh.. you have point, why should we have the statues and paintings in museum of those British murderers, who used to rule and plunder us. Sad, very sad indeed. If not much of a trouble, can we request you to please look at the meaning of some simple words known as – History, Museum and Posterity.

History -  A usually chronological record of events, as of the life or development of a people or institution, often including an explanation of or commentary on those events.

Museum - A building, place, or institution devoted to the acquisition, conservation, study, exhibition, and educational interpretation of objects having scientific, historical, or artistic value.

Posterity - all future generations of people.

We think that you went to a wrong place which people call a museum. You should have tried our Zoo’s or Circus, apt for a man of your taste. And believe me, you would have got some nice pictures to cherish.

Comparing two economic segments of a society is not an analysis, rather it is called dramatization, an attribute which will help you make better documentaries and write satires, but are of no use when it comes to understanding the dynamics and mechanics of the largest, and also a successful democracy.

In the end, the kind hearted but no-nonsense tolerant people of this country, will request you Not, repeat Not make any more visits and undergo a self-perceived and exaggerated suffering. And if you still chose to visit this country of diversity, culture, ethics, economic accomplishments and etiquettes, kindly contact us for therapy to correct your paranoid and cynically short sighted vision and outlook in life. People like you in developed countries have the largest cache of obtuse, ill-advised and baseless opinions, but fortunately we don’t need one.

PS : Please try using a lot of ‘We’ instead of ‘I’ while writing. It will help you become a better man…

Wednesday, 10 April 2013

Soldier's Brats'

Navneet Kaur Dhillon, crowned the latest beauty of the Nation at the Ponds Femina Miss India (PFMI) 2013 is a Soldier’s Brat. Closely followed by Sobhita Dhulipala from Visakhapatnam, adjudged the first runner-up, also a Naval offspring. Year after year, the beauty pageant has been dominated by adolescents’ having Defense backgrounds. The list is very long (we may have missed a few), but it includes Priyanka Chopra (Army), Lara Dutta (Air Force), Celina Jaitly (Army), Neha Dhupia (Navy), Sushmita Sen (Air Force), Pooja Batra (Army), Gul Panag (Army), Manpreet Brar (Army), Nikita Anand (Army), Ankita Shorey (Army), Kanishtha Dhankar (Navy), Hasleen Kaur (Army). Bollywood has many notables such as Anushka Sharma, Chritangda Singh, Shiney Ahuja (oops..), Ranvijay Singh, Akshay Kumar (not many that he is son of an Army officer late Hari Om Bhatia). These hellions have not only dominated the glamour world, some the other achievers include
Ajay Banga, President and CEO of Master Card.
Arnab Goswami, everyone knows him.
Jeev Milkha Singh, the first Indian professional golfer to become a member of the European Tour.
Nirupama Rao, she is the Indian Ambassador to USA.
Renuka Chowdary, Politician.
Sister Nirmala, who succeeded Mother Teresa.
So, what is that they imbibe in their childhood which the others miss out? Many say it is there upbringing which gives them an upper edge. Looking gorgeous has nothing to do with ancestry; but it’s the other attributes that makes the difference.
Discipline  -   Acclimatization in a soldierly environment permeates discipline in them. If you were to ask a hundred parents to describe their motives and methods of discipline, you might get a hundred different answers. But for a soldier and his family, it is simple - punctuality, obedience, respect for elders/superiors, conduct, sincerity, commitment and most important is to ‘understand limitations’.
Loyalty, Honesty and Integrity  -  Many would not be able to differentiate between the three, still this is the most powerful trio combo (like the Laxmi bomb of Diwali) which shapes their characters. It ain’t a gene in the semen or ova that gets genetically imprinted in them; rather it is in the atmosphere they breathe in every day.
Perseverance and Confidence  -  They learn the fact very early in life that diligence to hard work has no alternatives and detours. This gives them tenacity and endurance to face the world, and teaches them the seven stages of being successful – defining a goal, strong desire, building confidence, planning, cooperation, determination, and a fine execution.
Adaptability - Every 2-3 years leaving a place and migrating like nomads from one place to another is common acceptance for them. Leaving old friends, making new ones, from villages to metros, from Pathshala to Convents, from deserts to snow and from gulli danda to polo, is a spectrum of deprivations and opportunity that they get (depends of ones perspective). But, surly it evolves them from wag tailed fetus to a two legged mammal – adaption and survival. Separation from fathers makes them more responsible and gives them ability to take independent decisions, which most of us lack.

One can list a hundred other factors, if not more. Guess, they don’t learn to be successful, they just get the officer like qualities that their fathers live effortlessly with each day.

Sunday, 7 April 2013

Thane's Burial Ground

No terrorist attack, no natural calamity, no Korean Nukes but 74 people including 25 children died due to collapse of an engineering miracle. Surely, it was an engineering miracle - seven storey building constructed in two months under an invisible cloak, which is why no one from local municipality and police could notice it. The deceased are mostly poor daily wagers working at the construction site and their families. Of course, we are a nation of 1.2 Billion (frankly lost the count, because it is pointless to remember it now), and we won’t be missing these not so necessary souls. Some cooperators, directors of the municipalities, cops and builders will get arrested, remanded, paraded in a mockery of court room sittings and then finally getting discharged on 500 rupees surety bonds.  In a matter of another 48 hours the dead will die a death for ever. The news papers which printed the story in Headlines on Friday, will soon cover our kitchen shelves or clean the aftermath of a ejaculation.

Parliament attack 2001, a dozen died and the Army mobilized for another war, matter taken up in UN, national anger and millions spent beefing up security for MPs. 26/11 Mumbai, 164 died including 10 terrorists and thousands of riche riches discomforted because they could not enjoy their nightlife. Again Army mobilized, Pak militancy fostering raised in the highest levels of diplomacy, and once again millions spent on enhancing the security of the secured ones. There is no parallel between these two incidents and the Thane Building collapse, rather there is contrast; contrast of poor Vs the rich, terrorism Vs corruption.

So, how can we device a calibration to weight the cost of a human life and a commensurate response? Unfortunately there is no such index, and if one could invent, then definitely it would be the highest earning patent. These news excerpts gain our momentous sympathy, and later get lost. In fact none of us would even follow the outcome. Here are some more stories, though not associated with Thane incident, but we conveniently choose to ignore.

13 killed in Pune building collapse. Read more here.

Two dead, many injured in Delhi building collapse. read the full details here. More horror stories here.

This is not a neglect of our pre-occupation or busy life, it is a neglect of interest. If the same story read, “Salman’s New House Collapses – 74 Dead”, actions and reflections would have been different. Media would have visited the house of each dead in remotest corner of Bengal, UP, Bihar and Maharastra, and asked the same brainless question from their relatives, “Aap ko kaisa lag raha hae”.

This is our resilience, complaisance or immunity, and it will further catalyze numerous such more incidents, unless we ask ourselves…. 

  •     What should be the scale to decide the hullabaloo and public clamour for an incident and necessary corrective measures?

  •     It is an open secret that any builder, not only builders of high rise buildings but even individual constructing small houses, have to pay unofficial fees, to municipal officials, to get permission for their buildings' approval. What can be done to streamline the whole procedure?
  •     What should be the punishment for open defiance of Government’s rules and regulations? Why is this not “Culpable homicide amounting to murder”?

  •     Who all should be held responsible for this?

  •     Why do we have reactive attitude and not a pro-active approach? Do we have to wait for loss of lives to act?

Think India, THINK !!!

Neglecting Our Soldiers

A soldier is differently wired than any other central government employees. Reasons are abundant but primarily being the training imparted at the beginning of their career. The comradeship that is developed with each other during their stay, the bonding shared over running for miles, the hardships endured to complete the back breaking tasks assigned.The rooms, mess, PT schedule, fall-ins, classes and endless physicals all form part of shaping a young man into an officer. 

Today shortage of officers backed by bureaucratic delays in getting essential equipment and various other unknown causes has reduced the efficiency of the Indian Army. Lack of equipment and ammunition is also threatening the lives of our young soldiers. It is a known fact that after some years in service many officers get disillusioned with the working culture and power politics in play. The only thing that keeps pushing them and keeping the flame alive are the memories of those gentlemen cadets days and the oath taken at the time of commissioning to do their best for their Motherland.

IMA and NDA are two wonderful organizations that have been turning out impeccable officers for India’s 10 Lakh plus armed forces.

It is indeed a sad day one reads about cadets been forced to stay in plastic porta-cabins. Read full report here. 
 The walls of a squadron are adorned with proud displays of historic achievements of its alumni and spirit is what drives cadets, the very base of foundation of this training academies.

With what fondness and memories will they look back? This is a small discomfort compared to what they will have to face once deployed in field areas however does this logic warrant this kind of neglect? 

It is on open secret that the Indian Army is short of officers. Does it take rocket science to figure out that the solution would be to increase the intake? And does it really need to be spelled out that the intake to entail more seats in training institutions. What is really disturbing is the lack of voice being raised by the defense fraternity and the neglect of Indian bureaucrats and politicians. 

A stitch in time saves nine is a popular saying which the Indian government would do well to adhere to. Letting such prestigious institutions fall to ruin would be setting a very precedent. NDA is the nurturing place for warriors its needs should not be compromised.

  • Why is the Indian government taking defense matters so lightly?
  • Does the logic that on field soldiers face harsher conditions justification enough for treating new recruits like this?
  • Do we need a defeat in battlefield to make us change our ways?

Think India, THINK !!!

Friday, 5 April 2013

On Empty Stomach- Kejriwal


Americans find many things about India mystical and intriguing. One such American co-traveller started a discussion on Indians and our brains. He was writing a book on ‘Innovative Ideas to Cheat’ and choose the sub-continent to pick up case studies. The topic itself was not very comforting all things considered. He made a statement that day and probably it is best suited to Kejriwal today.

“If shamelessness of bullheaded Indians in power and administration could beconverted to       usable energy, then poor would not have been hungry in this country”

Kerjriwal’s latest abstention from eating is directed towards Shiela Dixit and probably a larger aim of seizing respectable vote bank during the upcoming Delhi Elections 2013. It is very difficult to have an opinion on people like Kejriwal and their actions. Is he really a Messiah or just trying to get some extra mileage?

Anyways, not going in to the necropsy of it, the question still remains is Angelic or ‘Ford Funded’ as secretly whispered? One does need to ponder why the public is not buying his fasting stunt while the same public lapped it up when Anna and Ramdev took to the stage? Is it the halo of simplicity and godliness which the people cannot see in Kejriwal? Kejriwal does come across has a man who knows his way in the world as well as the dirty insides of the Indian bureaucracy.

Wednesday, 3 April 2013

Sam Bahadur - Happy Birthday




Sam Bahadur or "Sam the Brave" was one of the best loved Indian Generals we could have ever had.

Born Sam Hormusji Framji Jamshedji Manekshaw he was among the first 40 intakes of Indian Military Academy. He has been instrumental in delivering India many victories.

As the Army chief his tussles with then Prime Minister Indira Gandhi are legendary.
 He brought glory of victory to the Indian army (humiliated by the unconditional surrenders of 1947).



At the end of April 1971, Indira Gandhi asked Gen. Sam Manekshaw if he was ready to go to war with East Pakistan. Manekshaw refused, citing the dispersal of his formations, the state of armour, the pending harvest which would vie for rail carriage, the open Himalayan passes and the coming monsoon. She asked the Cabinet to leave the room and the Chief to stay back. 

Gen. Manekshaw offered to resign on the grounds she chose.
Indira said,”You cannot deny a PM and I have to run the country”.

Sam said, “ Madam, you run the country but I will run the Army. Had your father taken the advice of his General in 1962, we would have not lost”.
Later, she declined declined his resignation and asked for his advice, he sought permission to prepare for the conflict and set the date and said he would guarantee victory. She agreed and permitted the General to prepare in his own way. The rest is history.